Being a good academic and mentor


Academics belong to The Academy – The name traces back to Plato’s school of philosophy, founded approximately 385 BC at Akademia, a sanctuary of Athena, the goddess of wisdom and skill, north of Athens, Greece.

World-wide ….without borders.

A key feature of being academic is taking a critical approach to engaging with knowledge. This disciplined rigorous thinking and questioning approach to research, problems, issues, and ideas is the  basis on which deep knowledge is gained and high achievement is fostered. [Southern Cross University: Centre for Teaching and Learning]

The medieval image of the university as an ivory tower, with scholars turned inward in solitary contemplation, immunized from the cares of the day, is an image that has been superseded by the modern university constructed not of ivory, but of a highly porous material, one that allows free diffusion in both directions. The academy is of the world, not apart from it. Its ideals, crafted over many generations, are meant to suffuse the national consciousness. [Princeton University’s 19th President, Shirley M. Tilghman, 2001

…scholars and teachers are meant to move in and out of the academy in pursuit of opportunities to use their expertise in public service, in pursuit of creative work that will give us illumination and insight and in pursuit of ways to turn laboratory discoveries into useful things. Our students engage the world with a strong sense of civic responsibility, and when they graduate they become alumni who do the same. This is as it should be. [Princeton University’s 19th President, Shirley M. Tilghman, 2001]


Source: “Empowering Delivery: Be a good academic role model and mentor”, Southern Cross University: Centre for Teaching and Learning,

Students often learn about what it means to be academic by looking at how their supervisors, lecturers and tutors interact with the student group, and other academics. Students also see the links teachers  make between their own knowledge and how they deliver their unit.


A key feature of being academic is taking a critical approach to engaging with knowledge. This disciplined rigorous thinking and questioning approach to research, problems, issues, and ideas is the  basis on which deep knowledge is gained and high achievement is fostered. There are many ways you  can be a good role model and mentor, and help students to be academic in their approach to study and learning in your discipline area.


The academic approach to learning uses a range of higher order thinking skills, processes and  dispositions or habits of mind (Vardi, 2013) and shows persistence and rigour. Model and make these as  part of the everyday life of your face-to-face and online classes, learning activities and interactions. What  you do and how you do this in class significantly impacts on the students’ approach to and engagement
with learning. Here are some ideas on how to be an effective role model.

Model the dispositions of a good critical thinker

Critical thinking is fundamental to taking an academic approach. Model the dispositions or habits of mind of a good critical thinker in your interactions with students by:

  • Demonstrating diligence in seeking information and the best possible solution
  • Clearly and honestly presenting your own and others positions or points of view
  • Engaging with students ideas
  • Showing that you are open and fair minded
  • Listening carefully to understand others reasoning and fairly appraise
  • Demonstrating your own inquisitiveness
  • Showing your passion for knowledge and your desire to be well-informed
  • Showing you are willing to re-consider your own views where it is warranted
  • Demonstrating and talking through your orderly thinking processes when working through complex issues and problems (Ennis, 1996; Facione, 1990; Vardi, 2013).

Demonstrating these dispositions in action and talking about them as they arise will help your students to see what academics do. It will help your students to understand what to do when you encourage them to be open, fair minded and knowledge-seeking about perspectives that are new to them, with knowledge that conflicts with what they currently believe, and any problems or issues.

Use intellectual language in your instruction

Use discipline specific language and words such as evidence, reasoning, logic, analysis, judgement and evaluation in your everyday conversation with students. Make this part of the way that everyone talks about knowledge, ideas, problems and issues in your class.

Weave an intellectual critical approach to learning into your classes by discussing with students:

  • The theoretical contexts that information comes from
  • Alternative theoretical concepts and perspectives that exist
  • How disciplinary knowledge has emerged and developed
  • Why the conclusions reached differ between different researchers
  • The disagreements and tensions in the discipline
  • How evidence was used to come to a particular conclusion
  • How and why the particular form of analysis or approach was taken.

Through these discussions, help students to see how this language and approach works in your discipline. Show them what counts as evidence and analysis, and what makes for credible sources in your area.

Use the skills and processes of rigorous thinking in your daily instruction

Help students successfully use the higher order thinking skills typical of your discipline by modelling and expecting students to practice these skills. Mentor them in their efforts. Demonstrate, talk through and encourage students to:

Keep class time and discussions focussed on –

  • The purpose of the question, problem or issue
  • The topic at hand
  • Relevant evidence and information

Ask probing questions and provide comment on

  • Evidence
  • Context
  • Data
  • Methods and techniques
  • Assumptions
  • Implications
  • Interpretations
  • Theoretical frameworks, perspectives and view points

Use a range of thinking skills appropriate to your discipline such as

  • Categorising
  • Comparing
  • Interpreting
  • Analysing
  • Evaluating
  • Inferring
  • Explaining.

When using these skills, demonstrate and talk about the need to:

  •  Avoid coming to a quick conclusion and sticking to that
  • Consider the context they are thinking about
  • Avoid giving more weight to information or conclusions that they already believe in
  • Consider all information before coming to a conclusion.

Using these skills consistently in your face to face and online interactions with students raises the level of discussion and depth of engagement. By doing so the academic approach to knowledge, problems, issues and questions is demonstrated to students, and forms a natural part of your interactions and expectations.

In summary

Make the academic approach to thinking, learning and knowledge an everyday part of your interactions with students. In this way, students will see how to think, behave and react in academically sound and robust ways. Your modelling, mentoring and encouragement will help develop learners who truly engage with knowledge, problems, issues and questions in an academic way.

Find out more

Ennis, R. H. (1996). Critical thinking dispositions:Their nature and assessability. Informal Logic, 18(2), 165-182.

Facione, P. A. (1990). Critical thinking: A statement of expert concensus for purposes of educational assessment and instruction Research findings and recommendations. (pp. 112). Newark, Del.: American Philosophical Association.

Paul, R., & Elder, L. (2001). Critical thinking: Tools for taking charge of your learning and your life. London: Prentice-Hall International (UK) Limited.

Paul, R., & Elder, L. (2006). The thinker’s guide to the art of socratic

Vardi, I. (2013). Developing students’ critical thinking in the higher education class. Milperra, NSW: Higher Education Research and Development Society of Australasia.




Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s